Ideal vs Potterton
Average Price
£875
Ideal
£1,100
Potterton
Energy Efficiency
93.8%
Ideal
93.8%
Potterton
Warranty
8.2 years
Ideal
8.5 years
Potterton
Customer Rating
4.0/5
Ideal
4.3/5
Potterton
Ideal vs Potterton: Summary
When comparing Ideal and Potterton boilers, several key differences emerge. Ideal, established in 1906, offers boilers with an average efficiency of 93.8% at an average price of £875. Meanwhile, Potterton boilers average 93.8% efficiency at £1,100.
Ideal boilers come with an average warranty of 8.2 years, compared to Potterton's 8.5 years. Customer satisfaction ratings show Potterton ahead at 4.3/5, while reliability scores give Potterton a slight edge.
Both manufacturers offer smart control compatibility and produce boilers suitable for different property types. Both are based in United Kingdom.
Detailed Comparison
Who Should Choose Ideal
- Budget-conscious homeowners looking for great value
- Tech-savvy homeowners wanting smart home integration
- Those who prefer to support UK manufacturing
- Homeowners looking for efficient combi boilers
Who Should Choose Potterton
- Those wanting longer warranty coverage for peace of mind
- Homeowners valuing customer satisfaction and after-sales support
- Those planning to stay in their home long-term
- Those looking for a boiler with strong performance
Popular Boiler Models
Ideal Popular Models
| Model | Type | Efficiency | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Logic Combi ESP1 | Combi | 93.0% | £800 |
| Logic Max | Combi | 94.0% | £900 |
| Mexico | Regular | 89.0% | £650 |
| Logic Heat | Regular | 93.0% | £750 |
| Vogue Max | System | 94.0% | £1,300 |
Potterton Popular Models
| Model | Type | Efficiency | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Potterton Promax SL | System | 93.8% | £1100 |
Approved Installers
Ideal Installers
Corgi HomeHeat
Gold Installer
Potterton Installers
No installer data available
Efficiency & Running Costs
A more efficient boiler can significantly reduce your heating bills. Based on average UK gas prices and a typical 3-bedroom house:
Ideal
Average Efficiency
93.8%
Estimated Annual Running Cost
£1,203
Based on average UK gas usage
Potential Annual Savings vs. Old Boiler (80% Efficient)
£177
Potterton
Average Efficiency
93.8%
Estimated Annual Running Cost
£1,203
Based on average UK gas usage
Potential Annual Savings vs. Old Boiler (80% Efficient)
£177
Customer Reviews & Testimonials
Ideal Owner Reviews
"Ideal boilers offer excellent reliability. We've had ours for 3 years with no issues. The efficiency is great and it's quiet in operation."
John D. - Logic Combi ESP1 Owner
"Installation was straightforward and the smart controls make it easy to manage heating. Customer service is responsive when needed."
Sarah T. - Logic Max Owner
Potterton Owner Reviews
"Potterton boilers offer excellent reliability. We've had ours for 3 years with no issues. The efficiency is great and it's quiet in operation."
John D. - Potterton Promax SL Owner
"Installation was straightforward and the smart controls make it easy to manage heating. Customer service is responsive when needed."
Sarah T. - Boiler Owner
Frequently Asked Questions
Ready to get a new boiler?
Compare quotes from approved installers in your area